Board Games guide
Dots and boxes strategy: chains, the double-cross and the long chain rule
Dots and boxes is won in the endgame. Avoid drawing the third side of any box for as long as you can. When every line gives something away, the board is made of chains of boxes: give away the shortest ones first, and when you take a long chain, use the double-cross (leave the last two boxes) to keep control, so the other player must open the next chain for you.
The rules
Start with a grid of dots. Players take turns to draw a line joining two dots that are next to each other, across or down. When a line completes the fourth side of a box, the player who drew it claims the box (write your initial in it) and must draw another line. When every line has been drawn, the player with more boxes wins.
The game goes back to the French mathematician Édouard Lucas, who described it in 1889. The standard board on Yuzool is 5 by 5 boxes (a 6 by 6 grid of dots).
Rule one: never draw the third side
A box with three sides drawn is a gift: the next player draws the fourth side, takes it, and draws again. So at the start of the game both players draw safe lines, lines that do not give any box its third side. The board fills up with boxes that have two sides drawn.
Eventually there are no safe lines left. Whoever has to move then must give something away. Everything that matters in dots and boxes happens from that moment.
Chains and loops
When no safe line is left, the boxes with two sides join up into chains (a row of boxes, each sharing an open side with the next) and loops (a chain whose ends meet). Drawing any line inside a chain gives the whole chain away: the other player takes the first box, then the next, all the way along.
- Short chains (one or two boxes) are cheap to give away.
- Long chains (three boxes or more) are where the game is won.
- Loops cost more to keep control of than chains.
So the player forced to move first gives away the smallest chain. A chain of two is best given away by drawing the line between its two boxes: then the taker cannot use the trick below.
The double-cross
Suppose the other player gives you a chain of five boxes. The obvious move is to take all five, but then you must draw the next line and give away the next chain. Instead, take three, and for the last two draw the line at the far end, leaving a pair of boxes that share one side. The other player takes both with a single line (a "double-cross") and must then open the next chain for you.
Worked example
The board has a chain of 5 and a chain of 6 left, and you are given the 5. Take all five, and you must open the 6: you end with 5, they get 6. Take three and leave two: they get 2 and must open the 6, which you take. You end with 3 + 6 = 9 against their 2.
Giving up two boxes to keep control is worth it whenever being in control of what is left is worth more than those two boxes. The Hard house player works this out every time.
The long chain rule
Because the player in control wins the long chains, the fight in the middle of the game is about who will have to open the first long chain. Counting the number of long chains (and the dots) tells you whether you want the number of safe moves left to be odd or even. Players who know the long chain rule make or break chains in the middle game so that the count comes out in their favour.
The simple version: the first player wants the number of dots plus the number of long chains to be even. The standard board has 36 dots, so there the first player wants an even number of long chains and the second player an odd number. The Hard player does not use the rule of thumb: when only a few safe lines are left it searches every order they can be drawn in and counts the chains at the end.
Strategy for beginners
- Count the safe lines as the board fills: you want the other player to run out first.
- Give away the shortest chain, and a chain of two by its middle line.
- Take every box you are given until you meet a long chain at the very end; then think about the double-cross.
- Beware of loops: keeping control of a loop costs you four boxes, not two.
Questions
What is the best strategy in dots and boxes?
Avoid drawing the third side of a box, give away the shortest chains, and use the double-cross (leaving the last two boxes of a chain) to keep control of the long chains at the end.
What is a double-cross in dots and boxes?
A single line that finishes two boxes at once. Leaving a pair of boxes for the other player to take this way forces them to move next, giving you the next chain.
Do you have to take a box when you can?
No. You may draw any line. Sometimes not taking the last two boxes of a chain wins more later.
Who invented dots and boxes?
It was described by the French mathematician Édouard Lucas in 1889, as la pipopipette.
What size board should I use?
The 5 by 5 board (6 by 6 dots) is the classic. Smaller boards are quick; bigger ones have more chains and a longer endgame.